My son made this fudge yesterday and I nagged him until he gave me the recipe. It's great!

With only a few ingredients, I was a bit hesitant to how it would turn out, but I am so pleased to say I love it! I just prepared it and had a blast licking the spoon, can't wait to eat it! Thank you xx

I think why it was grainy was because of how long you boiled the milk and sugar and also the kind of peanut butter you use. I know by using generic peanut butter it does come out grainy!

This was so simple. Very inexpensive to make. I did use real vanilla instead of imitation vanilla I learned that from my aunt. Can't wait to taste the fudge but I did get a little bit from the pan and that was awesome.

I just made this. Didn't realize that milk/sugar when boiled pops - burnt me lol. Although, I am going to do a little twist and add melted chocolate to the top and once cooled - perfection!! :) Thanks!

I think personally that this fudge was a little too sweet, maybe try 1 cup of sugar, or 1 1/2 cups?

Great recipe ! If it turns out to "runny" (like my first try) just add more PB.

Really was the easiest recipe I have seen for this fudge and came out very very good!!

This tastes amazing but I don't think I boiled for long enough. I'll try again sometime because it's great!

In love with this recipe :) I did a teeny bit of tweaking myself and used 1 cup of sugar and 1 cup ground unsalted peanuts. mmmm!

Best and easiest peanut butter fudge I've ever made! You can not go wrong with this one! Thank you!

Everybody that has eaten this fudge just can't get enough of it. It is so simple.

Made this tonight. It was so easy, turned out really good.

I just made it and it was not grainy. Started it out on medium heat and I kept whisking it for the 2 1/2 minutes then I poured it into my baking dish and set it to cool.

It was so good I made two batches and put pumpkin spice in one. My mom and dad loved them both. It is something I make all the time.