This is the same recipe my great grandma use to make. It's awesome! Better then any store bought icing. :)

Try this vanilla icing, came out ok but will try it again with less vanilla.

I think this recipe is... ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!! To the people who think that it is not good YOU PROBABLY DIDN'T MAKE IT RIGHT if it doesn't turn out right just add more milk. P.S I love baking even though I'm 11!!!!!!!

This icing was amazing my friends asked me how I got icing so sweet, I told them I got it off Cooks.com. They said they are going to look the recipe up.

This is the recipe we used as kids to make our graham cracker cookie sandwiches. Always turned out good and we used canned milk. Easy to color for fun.

This is a fun little recipe me and my family enjoyed very much! Not only is it easy to make, but it tastes amazing! It is less expensive and it is a completely no-stress recipe. All you gotta do is mix a few everyday ingredients together and you got a delicious icing for your cake! Love it!

Great recipe just really strong! If I added more milk it would get more drippy and yeah. It was pretty simple and I'm only 12.

I love this recipe. To make it easier I used a 1/2 cup of butter (1 stick) and fed in the sugar and vanilla a bit at a time. I used half-n-half and drizzled that in as well. That way I maintained the exact consistency I wanted all along. This can be colored or flavored any way we like - very easy! The only issue I encountered was that there was not enough to frost a 3 layer 8" cake so I would double it next time.

Very easy, quick, and tasty! Thank you.

I used unsweetened almond mink.... BEST FROSTING EVER! Delicious! Just melt to get lumps out.... SO QUICK AND EASY!

I made it and it was good. I added different flavorings, worked amazing but if it comes out too sweet just add a pinch of salt - cuts the sweetness a little.

I made it and it was great!!! No lumps and consistency was perfect.

I made it and it was great!!! No lumps and consistency was perfect.

This recipe is amazing... Delicious!!! Reminded of the icing my mother use to make. This has been bookmarked to my favs. Will add extra milk for added creaminess next time. :)

I love this frosting recipe! Its so easy! and taste amazing! i had to add a bit more sugar, bc it was a bit runny, but other then that its a pretty snazzy frosting.