This recipe is as close as I've found yet to my mother's recipe, which I have unfortunately lost. The only ingredient missing is butter, and I remember that it had to boil to 235°F. My problem is I don't remember the ingredient proportions. Anyone have the above recipe with butter also?

Easiest, creamiest peanut butter fudge I have ever made. Love that I didn't even need a candy thermometer!

WOW! Easy, Easy, Easy! I am so glad this recipe is on the top of the page. Tastes Great too!

I love this recipe. It's very easy to make, doesn;t take very long to make and it is delicious!!!!! I added chopped walnuts, and my husband loved it.

This is the best. I am 56 years old and recieved it from my x-mother in law in the 1970's. She was in her 80's, so you know this is a very old recipe.

It was great! It was easy,quick, and delicious! My grandaughter and I made it and it was great! We did one little tweak.. Add 1 tablespoon of marshmellow cream and it was awesome! my grandaughter doesn't really like peanut butter fudge, but she loves this!

Quickest and best peanut butter fudge recipe ive ever tried!

Soooo easy and soooooooo yummy! LOL

This is the best. Fast and easy. I subbed caramel essence for vanilla. Husband loves it. Thanks Jen.

Yes, it is grainy. Amazingly simple though!

I believe, in the South, we get only cane sugar, which is known to make candies grainy. Instructions did not imply stirring is needed, which I believe is another thing that can cause graininess. Will try again and stir while boiling to see if that makes a difference.

Great recipe!!! I chose to substitute a 1/2 cup of brown in and reduced the white sugar down to 1 1/2, but that's just becuase I had it and love brown sugar! Super easy and not gritty at all. Make sure you keep the milk and sugar mixture scraped down (not stuck to side of pan) while boiling... could be why some people are getting a gritty end product. Finally a REAL peanut butter fudge, not the melted down peanut butter chip kind!!! You can really taste the difference! Also, if you want to make it into an incredible candy... pour into a muffin pan to desired thickness to cool, once set dip into melted chocolate and place on wax paper to cool. Homemade peanut butter cups! YUM!

yes i made the easy peanut butter fudge and it came out gritty what did i do wrong

I just made this and it is so good! I always counted on my sister to make my PB fudge because I thought I would always mess it up. Now I can make it on my own :) THANK YOU!

This is the best peanut butter fudge. It is quick and easy, and it requires way less sugar than my other recipes.

Sorry mine turned out grainy too, but I let mine boil three minutes, and from the way it looked I think my next batch I'm going to try two minutes boil time.