POTATO PEANUT BUTTER CANDY 
1 baked or boiled sm. potato (cool)
1 box confectioners' sugar
Peanut butter
1 tsp. vanilla

Mashed potato and put vanilla in potato and add sugar until you can roll out like flour for a pie crust on wax paper. Roll out 4 x 12 inches. Smear peanut butter all over it then roll up in a roll. Cut and put in refrigerator to get hard. Bake.

recipe reviews
Potato Peanut Butter Candy
   #63144
 Renee (North Carolina) says:
My grandma taught me how to make this. Very good, cheap and easy to make. We use for holidays.
   #87488
 Diana (Ohio) says:
We have handed down this recipe for Christmas for 4 generations...the only thing I do different is to triple the recipe and my Mom & I started dividing it up and adding a lot of green food coloring to half and red food coloring to the other half...makes it look much more festive for Christmas.
   #113345
 Rebecca (Germany) says:
My Grandmother made this exact recipe every Christmas for my Grandfather and family/friends since the Great Depression. She never wrote it down an lead the family to believe she created this recipe. She taught me how to make it always eye balling an I've never used measuring cups or spoons. The last 8 years of her life the whole family thought she was still the one making it. She chucked an winked at me. I feel blessed for what she taught me.
   #160318
 KimWeasenforth (West Virginia) says:
This recipe was the best one I have found!!!
   #162201
 Nancy Robinette says:
Love this recipe, my mother used to make this for me as a child.

Related recipe search

“PEANUT BUTTER CANDY”

 

Recipe Index