Worm Dirt Cake / CM

RECIPE COLLECTION
“WORM DIRT CAKE” IS IN:
NEXT RECIPE:  ZOMBIE EYEBALLS

WORM DIRT CAKE 
This popular "novelty" cake is a hit at children's parties, especially around Halloween. You'll receive many appreciative compliments from your guests such as "Ewww, that's gross!"

It really resembles a pudding more than it does a conventional cake. If you serve it as an everyday family dessert, rather than as a fun decorative element, it's possible that your family may not understand it!

1 to 1 1/4 lb. pkg. Oreo cookies
1 (8 oz.) pkg. cream cheese
1/2 cup butter, softened
1 cup powdered sugar
3 cups milk
1 (12 oz.) tub Cool Whip (can use chocolate)
2 (3 1/2 oz.) pkg. instant vanilla or chocolate pudding
1/2 tsp. vanilla
4 gummy worms and/or other critters

Crush Oreos. Put 1/3 of the crushed Oreos into a new, clean flower pot. Set aside.

Mix butter, cream cheese and sugar and vanilla together. Set aside.

Combine milk and pudding mix. Fold Cool Whip into the pudding.

Fold together pudding mixture and butter-cream cheese mixture.

Layer this mixture (about 1/3 of it) onto the crumbled cookies in the pot. Next, add another layer of the pudding mixture, then another layer of cookie crumbs, continuing until all ingredients are used.

As you're layering the ingredients, decoratively place several gummy worms and critters in the "soil" so they will be seen emerging. If you have a toy (clean) garden trowel, a plastic daisy, or some edible flowers, these can also be used creatively to embellish the presentation.

Chill in refrigerator for 3 to 4 hours before serving.

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Worm Dirt Cake
 #9830
 Mary says:
I make this year round. I put it in a clean flower pot with artificial flowers for garnish & serve with a trowel.
 #9674
 Elisa says:
I have used the "lower" fat/calorie alternatives to the ingredients and it works out just the same... not that it lowers the "naughty" things THAT much... but it might make that little voice of "OH NO, I CANNOT EAT THAT!" in your head quiet. =-)
 #9038
 Heather says:
If you're going to take the cream center out, you might save yourself some time and just use chocolate wafers instead. =)
 #9275
 Trease replies:
What!!! The cream center is the best part!!!
 #9537
 Jessica replies:
Is it ok to lick the cream out of the Oreo's? Or should I use a knife? The cream is the best part of the cookies! Happy Halloween All!!!! :)
 #182353
 Donna Sullivan (Florida) replies:
Love your reply!!!
 #188784
 The (Indiana) replies:
Use a knife. If you're making it for a crowd, licking all the cream out would be unsanitary.
 #9025
 Elizabeth says:
I used a food processor to crush the Oreos - worked great - didn't have to remove the cream from the centers! It is a great recipe.
 #8835
 Amber says:
I found that it works better if you remove the cream from the center of the Oreos. I put the oreos in a plastic ziploc bag and use the bottom of a small cup to crush them. If I don't remove the cream from the centers, everything sticks together instead of coming out in crumbles like the recipe is intended to.
 #7922
 Kristen says:
To add a twist I recently decorated the top using tubed white decoration frosting making the outline of a racecar track with a few plastic tonka trucks... very cute
 #3700
 Penny says:
I have received numerous compliments when using this recipe! Absolutely the best dirt cake I've ever made (or ate)!

 

Recipe Index