Had 2 freezers going for a large party, made pineapple and chocolate for the pineapple. I just added a large can of crushed pineapple to mixture. Everyone said it was the best ice cream they had eaten. Best ice cream ever!

Can you substitute heavy cream for evaporated milk?

Can you substitute pasteurized eggs for eggs?

Yes. I use egg beaters. They are pasteurized.

Easy recipe but try substituting honey instead of granulated sugar. One cup of sugar = 3/4 cup of honey. It gives the vanilla ice cream a smoother texture and it is actually better for you. Oh, and it tastes fantastic!!

I made this recipe three times. My family loves it!

What size eggs are being used?

This is a good recipe I cook it though because of eggs. Also if you like coconut add 1 teaspoon to it. It will be the best ever coconut ice cream you ever tasted! I did this by accident when I confused the vanilla flavoring and coconut I had lol. Best mistake ever!

Hi Vicky, when you cook yours, do you heat the eggs with milk, then cool and whip and follow the recipe or do you follow the recipe as listed and then cook after it's all mixed together. Thanks!

Absolutely the best homemade ice cream I've ever made or eaten!

Best ice cream I ever made . Now I need an eight quart recipe if you have one. Please.

I'm not sure I made this correctly. The flavor is spot on! I fooled the recipe as best add i could. The eggs got foamy (how foamy are they supposed to be?). However, it says to beat mixture until stiff. Mine only got got to the consistency of cake batter. Very thick but not stiff. It didn't set up very well. I had it churning in ice cream maker for an hour and it was soupy. I froze the finish product over night and it did freeze but turned out very grainy. I'll keep at this until I get it right. Thanks for this delicious recipe.

Making me some ice cream now!

Do I use the whole egg or just the yolk.also what will thicken up the ice cream?

Hi Darrell,

The recipe calls for whole eggs. The eggs are what will thicken the ice cream.

-- CM

Hi Everyone,
I am so excited. Our family is having a birthday celebration for my daughter who is traveling down to Va from New Jersey and a High School graduation for my granddaughter. My have been constantly worrying me about making ice cream.
I have made before but will be trying this receipe for the first time. I can't wait to see how it will all turn out!
Wanda from Chesterfield, Va.

I can't wait to try this. I live in Texas and we no longer have ice cream available in stores due to the Blue Bell problem. I mean, there are other brands, but I don't know anyone who buys those. So, I can't wait to try this one. :D

I just received my ice maker and I am going to get the ingredients I need for this recipe. I will post to tell everyone my results in a few hours from now.