SWEETENED CONDENSED MILK
SUBSTITUTE
 
2 eggs
1 c. brown sugar
1 tsp. vanilla
2 tbsp. flour
1/2 tsp. baking powder
1/4 tsp. salt

Mix all ingredients and use as a substitute for sweetened condensed milk in recipes for pies, bars and desserts.

recipe reviews
Sweetened Condensed Milk Substitute
   #55201
 Barbara (Belgium) says:
I was in the middle of making some macaroons and realized I didn't have any condensed milk. I tried this recipe, and I think these are the best macaroons I've ever had!! Thanks so much for sharing!
   #56464
 Janet (Iowa) says:
Agreed! It is Christmas Eve and the last place I want to go when making fudge at 5AM is the grocery store in the freezing cold and snow! Every other recipe calls for dried milk... hello, if I am out of condensed milk I am probably out of dried milk! Ha! AWESOME!
   #56685
 Slambyd (Illinois) says:
I was skeptical... but this worked great for a microwave fudge recipe! Now I can't stop eating the fudge tho...
   #56858
 Tracy (New York) says:
I made a pumpkin pie using this substitute for sweetened condensed milk and was pleasantly surprised that it worked!! The texture of my pie was altered a bit, but not in a bad way. The taste was excellent.
   #56865
 Irene (New York) says:
This was a lifesaver! I was homesick and decided to make our traditional Cassava cake and realized that I had no condensed milk for the topping! We're in a midst of a snowstorm a day after Christmas here in NYC and the finished bibingka cassava brought me a little piece of Christmas from home. Thank you for this wonderful recipe!
 #57922
 Sarah (Idaho) says:
Hi there... I am trying to use this in the chocolate, graham cracker, coconut cookie bars and it calls for a 14 oz can of sweetened condensed milk... does the above recipe make the equivalent of a 14 oz can or should I double it?? Thanks for the help
   #59139
 Cori (Colorado) replies:
Fabulous! Equivalent to 14 oz. can - maybe little more. Warning- do not overmix in a mixer - makes eggs/vanilla frothy & therefore 'grows/foams' like marshmallow in recipe vs sinking in like reg sweetened condensed milk.
   #61033
 Paige (Oklahoma) says:
Amazing substitute! I didn't have this milk and needed it for a chocolate fudge recipe, it turned out fantastically thanks to this sub.

FYI - I didn't figure it out until I was measuring it that this makes ONE CUP but worked still perfectly for doubling.
   #61658
 Debbie (Alaska) says:
Super Substitute!! I used this for fudge on top of a Hershey's brownie recipe, had all ingredients besides sweetened condensed milk... Thank goodness 4 the internet!!!
   #67335
 Jess (Australia) says:
Quick, Easy and simple! Exactly what I needed in a hurry. And, there ingredients every one would have! Most importantly, it tastes great!!
   #72178
 Andrea Draper (Colorado) says:
Used due to lactose intolerance as a substitute in coconut pecan frosting for german chocolate cake and OMG it was delicious!! Thank you thank you thank you whoever figured this out. I'm one happy girl!
 #72247
 Fonz (Utah) says:
YAY! I was going to have a very unhappy son if we didn't have the traditional caramel popcorn for the fireworks. Thanks to this website... I am STILL "the best Mom ever."
   #74862
 Lydia (Florida) says:
Just what I was looking for! A Dairy-free substitute for sweetened condensed milk. Now I can make recipes that were off limits for our family. We have milk protein allergies.
   #85124
 Jenn (Alaska) says:
Thank goodness I came across this. I bought evaporated milk and not sweetened condensed milk. I thought I was out of luck since its the day before Thanksgiving. This saved my pies!
   #85128
 Emily (Washington) says:
HOW awesome is this! I made home-made dulce de leche from this recipe and it turned out wonderfully! My dad is lactose intolerant and i'm always trying to find new ways of cooking for him! turning the dulce de leche into frosting for cupcakes! Thanks again!
   #85148
 Ariel (Oregon) says:
THANK YOU SO MUCH! You are my savior. It is 5am and I just realized I didn't have condensed milk for my pumpkin pie!

 

Recipe Index