I made this recipe with my niece and nephew and it turned out wonderful. They had so much fun doing it and licking the bowl afterwards. It is wonderful :)

I had to add more milk and then was great! YUMMY

I think 3 cups is a little too much sugar for this recipe. It was not lumpy and spread well on the cake, but the sugar overpowers the vanilla. I think I will try cutting down on the sugar and maybe adding in some more butter?

for anyone saying that there was too much sugar or it didnt have enough milk and stuff, it does say "about" 2 Tbsp ! so dont get mad at the recipe just because you need to add a little more ! :P

If it's too sweet add 1/4 teaspoon of lemon juice.

This icing is horrible!! NEVER TRY THIS!!! I am a food critic and I have seen a lot of horrible recipes but this one is the worst that i have seen in the 27 years that I have been a food critic.

Extremely delish & super easy!! Used my KitchenAid mixer & beat for 3-5 minutes. Came out soo fluffy & light.. Did add an extra tbsp of milk also.. the more milk the fluffier it will be. FOOLPROOF!!

i made this and it was great. the only thing is that i put 1 cup of sugar instead of 3 cups and put some cream cheese and then i hit the jackpot.

Sooooo good!!!! I am only 11 years old, and i made it myself!!! It was a little too powdery at first, but i added more milk and it worked! =D YUUUUMMMMM!

Not too bad. I've tried many online recipes and this one is pretty simple. Just make sure to use more milk, a dabble of extra vanilla and a pinch more of sugar. "Play it by eye!"

This tastes really good!

Confectioners sugar means powdered sugar -.- its super good but we used wrong sugar! we are 12 ....

This recipe is so fast and simple to make! I reduced the amount of vanilla to 1 tsp. and added a little bit more than 1/4 tsp. of peppermint extract and it was amazing! If it is lumpy, add a bit more milk and beat it with a whisk or fork. Excellent!

Was daring...didn't have confectioners' sugar, had to use regular cane sugar. still turned out great! DARE TO BE DIFFERENT!

Amazing!!! The kid I was babysitting had a wonderful time making this it was simple and very easy to follow perfect for first time bakers!!! Definitely a keeper!!!