RECIPE COLLECTION
“THE WORLD'S BEST PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES” IS IN:

THE WORLD'S BEST PEANUT BUTTER
COOKIES
 
2 sticks butter
1 cup brown sugar
1 cup granulated sugar
2 eggs
1 1/2 cups peanut butter
2 1/2 cups flour
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp vanilla extract

Mix butter, sugar and peanut butter together. Add eggs, flour, baking soda and vanilla extract.

Bake at 350°F for about 12 minutes or until golden brown.

Yield: 3 dozen cookies

Submitted by: William III.

recipe reviews
The World's Best Peanut Butter Cookies
   #110744
 Susan (New York) says:
Truly the best receipe hands down. Tried other versions and keep going back to this one. Excellent. Thank you William III for posting.
   #109712
 Aine (Washington) says:
Fabulous cookies - the whole family absolutely loves them!
   #108676
 Teri Derma (Florida) says:
I made these cookies and everyone loved them. They are easy to make and need no refrigeration time... the best I've had in years :)
   #106777
 Laura (Wisconsin) says:
Just made these with my daughter and there amazing. lots of flavor :-)
   #106019
 Shannon (Florida) says:
Fabulous cookies! I put a full 2 cups of "Wowbutter" brand soy butter (Walmart) that tastes JUST like real peanut butter because I'm very allergic to peanuts and they turned out delicious! (and much healthier than real peanut butter too, by the way) I like my cookies soft on the inside so I baked them for exactly 10 mins @350°F (did the criss cross on top for nostalgia reasons lol! :)) Perfect!!! Thank you!
   #105648
 Amanda (United States) says:
I had a hankering for peanut butter cookies last night and came across this recipe. After reading the many reviews on hoe delicious these cookies were I decided to give them a try. While it did made a ton of cookies (52 to be exact using just half the dough) these was definitely NOT the worlds best peanut butter cookies.
   #105110
 Sandee Bothwell (Alberta) says:
Seriously good! These cookies spread so they are crisp and chewy. Love them!
   #103778
 Jazmine (California) says:
Came out great ~ could use a tiny bit more flavor, like almond extract maybe? I added half a cup of Nutella to give it a twist. Super yum!
   #100021
 Denise (Washington) says:
I made these for a coworker and my family. The best cookie ever I did the ten min but otherwise followed the recipe. Soft moist and delicious!
   #99656
 Dawn (Wisconsin) says:
These cookies were exactly what I was looking for. I wanted a recipe that used butter and not shortening, that tasted peanut-buttery, and had that classic peanut butter cookie texture. The only thing I did differently was to chill the dough for 2 hours before rolling into balls and flattening with a fork in the typical criss-cross pattern. After that I baked them exactly as the recipe said and they were perfect!
 #99414
 Tracy Kinard (Georgia) says:
I haven't tried this recipe yet. I was wondering if anyone has tried it using the new Honey Peanut Butter?
   #97941
 Roy (Maine) says:
Easy recipe, but they are NOT the world's best, they are dry and crumbly, not moist. I won't use this recipe again, and can't recommend it.
   #116205
 Channy (Pennsylvania) replies:
Whoever says these cookies aren't the best or that they are hard and dry, it has nothing to do w/ the cookie or the recipe, it's how YOU made them. Mine come out perfect every time.
   #95906
 The Mominator (Maryland) says:
Very good, but FYI the yield is 6 dozen, not 3 dozen.
   #95521
 Shari (Iowa) says:
Must have done something wrong, I like chewy cookies. These were hard and took a long time to bake.
   #95464
 Cara (Alberta) says:
Seriously delicious and wonderfully easy. Followed recipe exactly and they were perfect!

Related recipe search

“PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES”

 

Recipe Index