RECIPE COLLECTION
“THE BEST BREAD PUDDING” IS IN:
NEXT RECIPE:  TORTILLA PINWHEELS

THE BEST BREAD PUDDING 
Years ago on trying the amazing bread pudding at Movenpick on Yonge St. in Toronto, I asked the chef the secret (for his bread pudding)... "Almond extract" in addition to the vanilla is the secret. It is wonderful!

7 or 8 slices of white bread (broken into 3/4-inch pieces)
3 cups hot milk
2 beaten eggs
2/3 cup sugar
1/4 tsp. salt
1 tbsp. butter
1 1/2 tbsp. vanilla extract
1/2 tsp. cinnamon
1/2 tsp. nutmeg (+ sprinkle over top when in pan)
1/4 tsp. baking powder

Coat 8x12-inch casserole dish with butter. Pull bread into 3/4-inch pieces and put aside. Combine remaining ingredients and mix well. Add the bread and mix well.

Add to casserole dish and sprinkle with nutmeg.

Bake in 350°F oven for 45 minutes.

Submitted by: Jack Reddington

recipe reviews
The Best Bread Pudding
 #9268
 rod roberts says:
Try adding 1/4 cup cognac to your wonderful recipe for an awesome twist!
 #18803
 Reese says:
I see that all the bread pudding recipes call for a casserole dish. I don't have one, and am wondering if a long pan would be bad to use. Also, it would be great if someone would explain the difference. It is more than just size and shape? thank you!
 #18807
 Cooks.com replies:
Hi Reese,

A casserole dish is a baking dish that can also be used for serving, making for easier clean-up.

For most recipes, the pan size used isn't important other than that time may need to be adjusted depending upon how long it takes for the recipe to be cooked or heated through.

It's OK to use whatever pans you have that is large enough to contain the recipe with a little extra room for expansion and simply adjust time and temperature as needed.

-- CM
 #38597
 Marie (Maryland) replies:
I use a regular square cake pan like a brownie pan. That is what my Mom always used and it is fine.

By the way this is the closest to her recipe. THANK YOU. I finally can have it Just like Mom made it!
 #38952
 Carol Raabe (New York) says:
I made this recipe with stale chocolate chip brioche, added 1/4 tsp. of maple extract along with the vanilla and almond extracts and sprinkled the top with granulated maple sugar. YUM!
 #44069
 Dacia (Iowa) says:
I made this bread pudding the other day. It tasted better to me cold, the day after I made it. When it was freshly warm, it didn't have enough flavor to it.
 #44957
 Lisa (Virginia) says:
My Grandmother used to make a sauce to go over the bread pudding, anyone have any idea of what this would be?
 #45581
 Laurie (New York) replies:
I think it has been served with "Hard Sauce" A creamy white sauce with liquor in it?
 #45582
 Laurie (New York) replies:
I should have looked this up first! Hard sauce is butter, confectioners' sugar and Rum. My mom was born in Scotland and I remember her making hard sauce when I was a kid. Also served with Fig pudding.
 #181030
 Sandra Somerset (United Kingdom) replies:
Lisa, when we had Bread Pudding for school lunches, it was always served with a clear lemon sauce.
 #181636
 Dawn Mundy (United States) replies:
We live KY, in the middle of Bourbon country and we eat our bread pudding with a warm bourbon caramel butter sauce and it's amazing!! I have had chocolate bread pudding and fruit flavor ones and nothing beats this bourbon sauce.
   #187177
 Kathy Ferguson (California) replies:
I make a lemon sauce that is much like caramel. You mix butter, sugar and cream and a pinch of salt and when that is thick, you add fresh lemon juice and zest. It is divine!
   #189510
 Debra (North Dakota) replies:
If I want a lemon sauce, I just microwave a lemon pudding cup and pour it on the bread pudding.
   #190140
 Carla (Connecticut) replies:
The sauce that My mother put on her bread pudding came from Norway. She called it a lemon sauce. Unfortunately I was away when she passed and my sisters did not save her recipes but what I have found is most of her recipes are already here on this website so search for lemon sauce and if it's a sweet lemony thickened sauce that's what she put on with the bread pudding. She also put raisins in her bread pudding.
 #45598
 Karen Thode (Iowa) says:
This was an AWESOME recipe and I had never made bread pudding!! I did use the almond flavoring and it IS recommended to do!! The next time, I will add raisins. I also found a great recipe for a sauce to use: 1 cup white sugar, 4 tbsp. white flour and 1/4 tsp. of salt. Mix together and then slowly add 3 cups of boiling water. Place on low heat and simmer until thick and then add 4 tbsp. butter and 2 tsp. of vanilla. Pour over the top of pudding and ENJOY! :)
 #45680
 Terry Madison (Florida) says:
I've always loved the lemon sauce Cunningham's in Louisville, Ky serves on their bread pudding. This is one of my favorites
 #46089
 Loni Landry (Illinois) says:
Instead of using bread try using day-old donuts. Different types of bread can be used even buns! You can also drop by the spoonful, your favorite pie filling after you have all the dish finished and ready for the oven. Try adding 1/2 cup of cocoa powder for that chocolate tooth I know alot of people have.

Rum extract and raisins are a nice holiday treat when added. Add by the spoonfull some of your pumpkin pie filling for a Thanksgiving treat! Add some apples, walnuts, and raisins for fall weather enjoyment! Even adding in some candied nuts is a tasty treat.

At Christmas try serving bread pudding hot topped with some peppermint icecream!

In the summer add you favorite fresh fruit, apples, bananas, peaches, plums,...etc... You can even try adding your favorite pudding mixes by the spoonfull to mix things up! Custard dropped by the spoonfull with caramel icecream topping drizzled over the top before baking makes a nice end to a good meal anytime! Don't be afraid to mix and match your favorite things with bread pudding!

Enjoy these tips and happy eating and cooking!
 #46092
 Loni Landry (Illinois) says:
Try spreading strawberry jelly, jam, or perserves over hot pudding! For those of you who enjoy your pudding cold, put plastic wrap over the top of the pan as soon as it has cool enough not to melt the plastic but before you place pudding into the refregorater. This will give it a more creamy taste after it because cold!
 #46262
 Sharon Martin (Michigan) says:
Make it easy on yourself, put all of the ingredients in your blender and BUZZZZZ, pour it on your bread, and Raisens, (if you like it a bit sweeter), and increase your cinnamon to about a teaspoon, with more on top. Save oven time by warming it up in the microwave.
   #63395
 Melissa (Pennsylvania) says:
I made this bread pudding with cinnamon raisin bread. AMAZING!!
   #73794
 Jan (Nebraska) says:
I have made this using a 9x13-inch pan, and instead of using bread I have used old cinnamon rolls and adding a little more of the cinnamon. Eating this warm is awesome, adding cool whip is excellent. Makes your home smell right good!
 #83106
 L.F. (Germany) says:
I add chopped apples and raisins to my bread pudding. Soooo delicious! I also use soft whole wheat sandwich bread - (still tastes great and makes it a lit healthier)! :)
   #189511
 Debra (North Dakota) replies:
One of our local cafes had apple/raisin bread pudding with caramel sauce... very good!
   #94689
 Zetty (Oklahoma) says:
Very tasty. Thanks for the recipe!
   #131367
 Miike (Oregon) says:
Had a bread pudding at an old hotel in Washington state that was made with toasted egg bread and a rum sauce. I'll NEVER forget it... Best I've ever had in my, almost 80, years. This had raisins and was baked in a water bath to keep it moist thru the bake...

 

Recipe Index