Combine ingredients in a blender or mix well in a bowl. Sprinkle top with nutmeg and bake. ENJOY. Turns out perfect everytime.

Love this recipe! I made it tonight for dinner with guests. My husband, however, would like it without coconut. Could it work "as is", just leaving coconut out of the recipe?

This is so easy and soooo good. Someone asked if you could leave the coconut out for a custard pie. You can bit you need to crumble in a slice of bread if I remember correctly. Just look under bisquick impossible custard pie to get the correct measurements. I wait until cool then drizzle with chocolate. I have also added lime juice for 1/4 of liquid, then added lime zest with coconut to give that lime and coconut twist.

This is the BEST coconut custard pie you will ever make. So fast and easy and it is a crowd pleaser. Excellent recipe.

Can u use almond milk in coconut custard pie in place of regular milk

Why not try coconut milk? If you use almond milk it won't be as creamy as real milk.

Can you use plain flour instead of Bisquick?

No!! It won't work. The Bisquick is what makes it impossible!

Could I bake in muffin tins in cupcake liners?