GERMAN RHINELAND SAUERBRATEN 
1 kg beef
1 onion
4 peppercorns
2 cloves
1 bay leaf
1/4 liter vinegar
3/8 liter water
salt and pepper
sour cream
corn flour and water
Maggi liquid seasoning

Being German and never finding a traditional recipe online (no matter how many I have looked at), I asked my Oma for hers.

We do not ever use ginger snaps and anything else you may find that sounds American, so the ones I've found are not anywhere near traditional German food.

This is for the pure German Sauerbraten from Koln, uninfluenced and had not changed for thousands of years.

Wash and dry beef, place in large cook pot or bowl; chop onion and place all other ingredients in bowl to marinate (except for the sour cream and corn flour).

Place in cupboard to marinate, turning every day to allow all of the meat to become infused with spices. Marinating should be allowed to take place over 4-7 days. Remove meat from the marinade and place in pre-heated oven at 180°C with a small amount of water to prevent burning and sticking.

Dook until done to your liking. Mix corn flour and water to make paste for gravy.

Pour meat juices from pan and marinade into saucepan, bring to the boil and add corn flour to thicken, Maggi seasoning to taste.

Finally add sour cream to make gravy creamy and serve wtih dumplings and vegetables.

Cook's Note: To modernize this recipe, marinate meat in refrigerator and discard any used marinade - use only fresh marinade in the gravy preparation.

Submitted by: vanessa

recipe reviews
German Rhineland Sauerbraten
 #2846
 Chris says:
Well, before even trying this I have to say this is probably the most authentic recipe I've seen. No ginger snaps and Maggi! Was actually surprised to see the Maggi. Good stuff.

For those of you not familiar with it, well, for lack of a better explanation it's German soy sauce - kind of.

Thanks for the recipe - Vanessa.
 #13437
 Konrad says:
I'm of german heritage, but i've never actually have had German food. I'm glad I finally found something real.
Thanks.

-- Konrad
 #18951
 Deborah says:
My Grandmother & great grandmother both came here from Germany, and they made ginger snap gravy with raisins to serve with the sauerbraten. I think it's a regional thing, but very authentic.
 #20293
 anke (Pennsylvania) says:
Thanks so much!!! I am originally from Wuppertal, which is right next door to Koeln! I love this recipe, my mother would be proud! :) I am making this tomorrow :)
 #22238
 Beverly (Colorado) says:
My family is from Schwabisch Hall, and I have to say we never made our Sauerbraten with raisins or gingersnaps either. German food is extremely regional, almost militantly so, just ask two Germans about Bratwurst... :) I have to tell you, this recipe is the closest to my Oma's also, except in later years she added a 12 oz. can of Coke.
 #22239
 Beverly (Colorado) says:
O, and the Maggi? OMG, the absolute best all purpose seasoning you can imagine! I used to have to bring mine back when I went on vacation, but now you can get it at Safeway.
 #47929
 TomK (Connecticut) replies:
I did not know that "Maggie" liquid seasoning has been around for 1,000 years!
 #173857
 David Michael Bell (Illinois) replies:
There was no Maggi one thousand years ago, or even a hundred years ago, and corn was unknown in pre-Colombian Europe, introduced only after it was brought back from the New World expeditions of Spain. Point being, there is no "right" or "wrong" in many recipes including sauerbraten. I like Alton Brown's simply and easy recipe which call for brown the meat prior to marinating it. Though browning the meat first strikes me as not very authentic, given that sauerbraten recipes originated as a way to preserve meat without refrigeration, the end result was fine and the cooking process simplified, i.e., no need to remove meat, dry, brown, and return to a braising vessel, rather simply flip the switch of your crock pot (assuming you marinated it in same).
   #77693
 Petra (Illinois) replies:
Maggi is the reason why I'm following this recipe. I was born is Saar-land, Germany. It is very hard to find Maggi here. We use it all the time. I lost my momma's recipe, so that's why I looked it up. Thank you, Vanessa
 #25499
 Mary (United States) says:
Can any of you with strong ties to your German heritage help me find a recipe? My ex-mother-in-law would make ham, German potato dumplings with sour cream gravy. I know she used the juice from the ham and she put bay leaf in with the ham while it cooked. The only other thing I know is she used vinegar, but I don't think it had actual sour cream in it. I'm not sure about the last part. Of course my ex won't give up the recipe! I found a recipe for the potato dumplings just need help with the gravy. Thanks!! Mary
   #108511
 Rick Meyers (Colorado) says:
This recipe look very close to my mothers, She used ginger snaps, I know that in many old old recipes ginger and pepper were interchangeable. I question the use of corn flour since ear corn is an American grain. But if it is delicious who cares.
   #110113
 Stefan (Massachusetts) says:
This is great "rheinischer Sauerbraten" - great recipe thanks!. The raisins/gingersnap part (actually one would use Lebkuchen not gingersnap) is a regional southern thing - my grandma used to make it that way
   #124849
 Charlotte (Colorado) says:
Hi Vannesa, I haven't tried however it is closest to my mothers recipe! My Dad just passed away and I want to make my Moms Sauerbraten and hopefully my Dads potato dumplings. I had only made once long ago couldn't remember how much of clove, and vinegar thanks to you and your Oma for the post!
 #130961
 Melody (Pennsylvania) says:
We were stationed in Germany in the 80s and during the time the wall came down. I have looked many times for this recipe having it while in Germany and this is the first time I have found the right thing.
   #136471
 Gail (Florida) says:
Finally!!!! No gingersnaps and add sour cream. This is my Oma's recipe! Whoot Whoot!
 #142233
 Andrew Werst (Pennsylvania) says:
Thank you Vanessa for authentic. Have been searching for real thing and anxious to try your Oma's. German on Fathers side and want to treat for Holidays. Thank you. A.Werst in Pennsylvania.
 #154761
 Marbo (Washington) says:
I have to agree with what others have said about being a regional thing, re using gingersnaps and raisins. When we were in Germany in the late 1960's, we ate at a German restaurant in Bertchesgarten. Mom and I had the sauerbraten and it DID have gingersnaps and raisins, and NO sour cream. No cornstarch or flour was used for thickening, only the snaps. Their cook said that it is a traditional Christmas dish, and they normally used lebkuchen, but since this was in May, they used more readily available gingersnaps instead.
   #161341
 Susan (United States) says:
You are so right - there were never ginger snaps in my mom's sauerbraten. I never got the recipe from her before she passed. But the taste of this one comes so darn close. Sincere thanks.

 

Recipe Index