RECIPE COLLECTION
“HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER (COOKING SCHOOL)” IS IN:

HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER (COOKING
SCHOOL)
 
In these times, it pays many dividends to prepare your own fresh and wholesome peanut butter at home.

Spread raw in-shell peanuts evenly on a cookie sheet and bake in a preheated 350°F oven for 15-20 minutes, stirring often. When the peanuts are done, the shell will become brittle, and the peanuts skin will slip off easily. They will be light brown and have a roasted flavor.

Peanut butter made at home does not keep for as long a time as commercially prepared peanut butter because there are no preservatives. On the plus side, it is far less likely to be tainted by foreign matter and/or Salmonella when you make it yourself.

Prepare it in small batches and store under refrigeration. Peanut butter made at home may not be as heavy as what you're accustomed to but it also doesn't contain hydrogenated shortening and trans-fats. When prepared using pure peanut oil, it can sometimes separate as the oil rises to the top of the jar in storage. Simply turn the jar upside down in the refrigerator, or stir the extra peanut oil back down. Vegetable oil may also be used, but we prefer to use peanut oil.

Shell the peanuts and rub the inner skins off the outside after they've been roasted. A clean cotton terry towel may be used to rub off the papery film.

Place 1 cup of freshly roasted and shelled peanuts (with the skins removed) into a blender or food processor container. Turn the blender on and while running, drizzle 2 tablespoons of peanut oil in through the small opening in the cover. Add about 1/2 teaspoon of salt, if desired, and process until smooth. If you prefer a slightly sweet version, add a tablespoon of honey or Karo syrup. Molasses is a healthy sweetener if you like the flavor. If your favorite sandwich spread is crunchy peanut butter, stir in some extra crushed peanuts.

If a food processor is used, larger batches may be prepared than when a blender is used. Use a ratio of 2 tablespoons of peanut oil for each cup of peanuts. Spanish peanuts have a large quantity of oil (you may be able to reduce the amount of oil used), and make a creamy peanut butter, while Virginia peanuts provide a full flavor and texture. Try combinations of the two; 1 cup Spanish peanuts and 2 cups Virginia peanuts is a good combination which usually requires no added oil in the preparation. Store under refrigeration.

Once you become a peanut butter aficionado and are comfortable with the technique of making peanut butter at home, try making other nut butters, such as cashew butter, almond butter, or even Macadamia nut butter! Nut butters are highly nutritious and packed with valuable vitamins, minerals and proteins. When made with peanut oil at home, these staples of the lunchbox are a safe and superior product to what may be found on the supermarket shelves.

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Homemade Peanut Butter (Cooking School)
   #130821
 Yunahime (France) says:
Thank you so much for this recipe because I've always found that shop bought peanut butter was expensive compared to the ordinary peanuts price. And I was also worried about the hydrogenated fat content. I just use lightly salted peanuts and don't feel the need to add any oil.
 #132297
 L. Turner (California) says:
I have made my own homemade peanut butter for several years now. I only use 2 lbs of peanuts. That is what my cookie sheet will comfortably hold. It is also just the right amount for the food processor to do the job w/o taxing the motor. We add a little bit of peanut oil just to soften the peanut butter so it stays soft after it is refrigerated.
   #158347
 Mike (United States) says:
We use peanuts from Sam's or Costco.
We add no oil as the peanuts have enough in them. We use a direct drive food processor with the metal blade. Add several cups at a time and be patient, it will get smooth. Hold back a cup or two of peanuts to make crunchy and add during last blend. As there are no preserves it MUST be kept in refrigerator.
A nice dip is equal parts of cream cheese and home made peanut butter and your choice of jam/jelly. Blend and dip fresh fruit or veggies. Enjoy
   #174219
 Tracy (North Carolina) says:
I grow peanuts and have a ton... should I just keep them stored in my basement and make one batch at a time, or shell them and make a lot of peanut butter? I'm afraid that extra batches will go bad even in the frig...
   #183903
 Jack Matthies (Nebraska) replies:
Wish we had the problem of too many peanuts here in Nebraska!
 #180525
 Be (Texas) says:
I use olive oil for any nut butter I make for myself.
 #180679
 Renea (California) says:
I buy raw shelled peanuts and put them in 2 lb bags. That amount will fit a regular size cookie sheet. I roast them and when they are done I let them cool for a few minutes before putting them in the food processor and a turning it on high. You do not need to add oil or a sweetener to help them blend. I process until smooth and creamy and a small amount of peanut oil for smoothness. This amount of peanut butter will fill a large "Laura Scudder" jar plus a little extra. I then extra. I seal the jar and then turn it over until cooled.You do not need to add sugar or salt or extra oil. Please refrigerate. It will keep a long time in the refrigerator.

 

Recipe Index