CRISCO FROSTING 
4 tbsp. flour
1 cup milk
1/2 cup Crisco
1/2 cup butter
1 cup granulated sugar
2 tsp. vanilla

Cook together flour and milk, stirring constantly, until thick like custard. Refrigerate until very cold. Then cream together Crisco, butter and sugar until no longer grainy. Add flour mixture and vanilla and continue beating until very smooth and creamy.

recipe reviews
Crisco Frosting
 #192755
 Keith (New Jersey) says:
I've been making for years. However it comes out loose and my cake slides. Thoughts?
   #193654
 Pfyre (Illinois) says:
My mother made this frosting for decades because my father and brother loved it. I, personally, got tired of it by the time I was in high school. But I'm glad I found the recipe again.

TWO THINGS that should be noted. FIRST - the cooked down flour and milk can be quickly cooled by setting the sauce pan into a sink partially filled with ice and cold water. It is much faster than just putting it into a refrigerator. SECOND - the mixing of the cooled flour and milk with the remaining ingredients should be for a MINIMUM pf SEVEN (7) MINUTES. And if the recipe is doubled [my mother did this most times she made the icing and would use 1 batch to immediately frost a cake and would freeze the 2nd batch for use on a later cake] the time for mixing is also doubled.

 

Recipe Index