RECIPE COLLECTION
“GRANDMOTHER'S ORIGINAL OATMEAL RAISIN COOKIE” IS IN:
NEXT RECIPE:  GUAVA FRUIT SQUARES

GRANDMOTHER'S ORIGINAL OATMEAL
RAISIN COOKIE
 
1/2 cup butter
1/2 cup lard
2 eggs
1 cup sugar
2 cups flour
2 cups oatmeal
1 tsp. cinnamon
1 tsp. nutmeg
1 tsp. salt
1 tsp. baking soda
1 tsp. vanilla
1 cup raisins

I remember Grandmother making these when I was a kid, I thought they were amazing. Grandmother passed away in her late 80's a few years back. I was fortunate to have been able to get her old hoosier cabinet moved in to my house the other day and while I was cleaning it, I discovered this recipe, so I decided to make me a batch, as good as I remember. There were no mixing instructions nor a heat setting. It was hand written by pencil on a very old looking piece of paper, we suspect this recipe was handed down at least at a time when they used lard and cooked on a stove heated with wood.

Oven 350-375°F.

Bring a small sauce pan of water to boil about a 2 cups. Add raisins and boil 10 minutes. Measure out 2 cups flour (I sifted the flour) in a large bowl add your eggs, sugar, butter and lard (yes I used lard, you could sub equal amount of shortening).

Begin mixing at a low speed, then add 5 tablespoons of the water from your raisins. Add in the cinnamon, nutmeg, baking soda and vanilla. Add in the oats (I used Quaker old fashioned).

Drain the raisins, then add the now cooked raisins to the mixture. Blend well on low speed, just don't beat up the raisin too much. That's why we do them last.

Drop by the spoonful onto a cookie sheet. Bake in the oven for about 8 minutes. I think they are better pulled out just a wee bit soft, much better than browned, a good way to tell is they should just start to brown on top.

What's interesting about this oatmeal cookie recipe is that is does not use brown sugar, uses lard and boiled raisin water. I have never seen a recipe quite like this, if you have some comments about it I would be interested to hear from you. peerybrown@gmail. com

I think modern cooking needs to go back to its roots, I like the old ways of cooking things I guess.

note: I am sure you health nuts out there are gonna go nuts over the use of a 1/2 cup of lard, but I will tell you this, all of my old relatives lived well right up into their late 80's, and 90's and they didn't do that on hydrogenated oil derived from vegetables. I use only butter and lard in all recipes, natural is better, moderation is key. -enjoy, PB

Submitted by: Virginia Elizabeth Brown (in memory of)

recipe reviews
Grandmother's Original Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
   #55496
 Shin (New York) says:
I have not tried the recipe as yet but sure will later today. I like the facts you stated about your relatves who cooked using the things they did lived to be the ages they were. I am originally from a country where they cooked wth lard and butter for everything and raw sugar as we had a sugar factory that imported the raw sugar. The people of that land lived even up to 102 years old still walking and taking with little eye sight and hearing problems. So I must agree with you until they started messing with the food and agriculture we were not having the problems that exist now and people were living longer.
   #64175
 Larissa McCraner (Michigan) says:
I made these last night and they are very good and my husband hasn't left them alone since they came out of the oven. I think they do turn out better if you only let them get slightly gold on top. It is a keeper in my opinion.
 #120989
 Rachel Pearson (Ohio) says:
Love the story behind this recipe! Family recipes are the best...you get memories along with the satisfaction of cooking homemade. And I agree with you - moderation is the secret. This recipe is very different from most, but good. Thank you very much for sharing!
   #147804
 Getinmybelly ! (New Jersey) says:
I had fun making this in my stand mixer and, actually worked out great baking in the convection toaster oven at 375°F for 10 minutes per batch. VERY GOOD AND, THANK YOU for posting this!
   #153308
 Mary virginia (Wisconsin) says:
Well Virginia Elizabeth...the recipe is wonderful, I render my own lard and agree with you about everything. Thanks for sharing. My mother was Virginia Elizabeth too!
   #172238
 Edie Rich (Florida) says:
I loved them. The recipe calls for 2 c. oats, I did 4-1/2. So the 2 c. might be a type o. I let mine brown till the bottoms of some got nice and brown, and did some till just light brown on top., Both ways were GREAT. I also added chopped walnuts. Still GREAT. Thank you.

E.D.R.
   #182800
 Jim C (Missouri) says:
Thank you for the recipe, I was looking for a oatmeal cookie using LARD! Both my grandmothers used lard in their baking of both cookies and oh so flaky piecrust, which would melt in your mouth. Both of them grew-up on farms, one from the oldie south DOB: 1892, the other in the north DOB: 1906, but they baked and cooked pretty much the same way. (Oh... I can't forget my mother's grease pot sitting on top of the stove.) They grew everything they ate, including the animals. Storing the canning and root vegetables in the storm cellar for winter use. My point is, what kills us today, kept them healthy and it all comes down to different lifestyles. Every one of them worked hard, in the heat, cold, rain and snow. Everything put on the table helped get them to the next day. Today, if we get hot or cold, turn the thermostat one way are another, while waiting for the seat heater in the car to warm up. Having a cheeseburger every blue moon isn't going to kill you, nor oatmeal cookies. Thank God for lard, (fat) are a few of us today, may not be here! Thanks again.
   #185825
 Donna Burt (United States) says:
This is exactly my Grandmother's recipe, it makes fabulous cookies! Use the lard, otherwise they won't be moist!
   #189454
 Ila miller (Pennsylvania) says:
Do you mix the flour with the spices?
   #190165
 Tee (California) says:
It was OK. Will not boil raisins again. Do not like this goo, wet textures of raisins.

Related recipe search

“OATMEAL RAISIN COOKIE”

 

Recipe Index