How to Make Pierogi / CM

RECIPE COLLECTION
“PIEROGI” IS IN:

PIEROGI 
Dough:

3 1/2 cups all purpose flour
3 large eggs
2 tablespoons sour cream, buttermilk, or plain yogurt
1 cup water (more if required)
butter or olive oil
salt and pepper

Combine flour, half of the water, eggs, melted butter or oil, and the sour cream, buttermilk or yogurt in a large bowl. Stir vigorously to incorporate the eggs.

Slowly stir in the remaining (warm - not hot) water until a dough begins to form. Turn out onto a floured surface and knead gently, lifting dough to stretch.

Continue lifting and stretching the dough until the dough is smooth and somewhat sticky inside, about 3 minutes or so. Do not overwork the dough - if it begins to become elastic, allow it to rest 5-10 minutes under an overturned bowl before working with it again.

When the dough has been kneaded enough, place in a storage bag in the refrigerator to rest 20 minutes, or leave on the counter under an overturned bowl 30 minutes, to allow any gluten which may have developed to rest.

While the dough is resting, you can prepare the filling.

Filling:

3 medium or 2 very large waxy potatoes (baking)
3 tablespoons unsalted butter
1-2 tablespoons butter, olive oil (or schmaltz)
1 large onion, minced
2-3 cloves garlic, minced
2 cups cabbage, finely shredded
1 small leek, finely minced (optional)
2 tablespoons Parmesan or white cheddar cheese, grated

Cook the potatoes in their jackets, in a covered heavy pot with barely enough water to cover them in slightly salted water (add about 2 tsp salt to the water). Simmer over low heat until potatoes are fork tender, then remove from heat. (If you can judge when they'll be done, remove from heat 10 minutes in advance and just allow to steam in the pot with the heat turned off).

Allow the potatoes to cool sufficiently to handle, and rub off the skins with a clean towel. Drain the pot you cooked them in, and return the potatoes to the pot and shake them around a bit to dry them.

Put the potatoes through a sieve or a potato ricer if you have one, otherwise, use a masher. Set them aside.

In a skillet, combine butter, oil (or schmaltz) over medium heat to melt. Sauté the onion, and leek, if you have one, for a few minutes until they begin to take on a translucent color.

Stir in the cabbage, turn the heat to high for 1-2 minutes, stirring constantly, reduce heat and allow cabbage to begin to brown, 6-8 minutes adding the garlic as the cabbage begins to brown. Then add the potatoes, cheese, and season to taste. Remove from heat and go on to work with the dough again as the filling cools.

Remove the dough from the refrigerator (allow it to warm at room temperature for a few minutes) and form it into balls 1 1/2 to 2" in diameter. Roll each out with a rolling pin into a 3-3 1/2" round approximately 1/8 inch in thickness. Cover the ones you've made with a damp paper towel as you work. If you prefer, you can use a pasta machine to roll out the dough circles. Be sure to flour both sides lightly first.

Hold the dough in one hand, and place a round ball of filling or spoonful into the center. Fold in half to enclose the filling, and pinch the edges securely together. Don't allow filling to touch the edges to avoid an imperfect seal. Be sure there are no openings along the edges, or the filling will boil out.

Boil a large pot of salted water as you continue to fill the remaining pierogi until all the ingredients run out. As you work, place a sheet of waxed paper dusted lightly with flour or corn meal over and between the pierogi layers until ready to boil.

Cooking: Gently lower pierogi into rapidly boiling water 3-5 at a time and cook for a few minutes until they float to the surface, then 2 or 3 minutes more (taste test one!). Remove with a slotted spoon and continue til all are cooked.

Serve fresh with melted butter, or sauté in butter and chopped onions until lightly brown on outside.

An alternative to cooking these in water is to boil them in the broth remaining from a boiled ham, or in chicken broth.

NOTE: If your pierogi are too doughy, you either rolled the dough circles so they were not thin enough, or if their thickness was correct, they may not have been evenly rolled or cooked sufficiently. The first attempt is not always perfect, but if you note where you could have done better, your next batch will be much improved!

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Pierogi
   #176953
 John L. Twarog (Pennsylvania) says:
We use a bread machine for the dough and have a 6 position mould for stuffing the pierogi. It makes fast work for us as we make 15-20 dozen for the holidays.
 #146012
 Denise (California) says:
We always loved the pork and sauerkraut Pierogi. We also have the potato and cheese but my favorite is pork and sauerkraut. We also make Golabki (stuffed cabbage) and Haluski (raw potato dumplings with sautéed cabbage). I am from a large Polish and Sicilian family.
 #141104
 Maddy (United States) says:
Try them with bacon and sauerkraut. They're yummy also with large cottage cheese ;) You'll love them.
 #131112
 Joan Graeser (Pennsylvania) says:
Just a hint: I use my noodle maker to roll out the dough to the right thickness and all you have to do is cut the (lasagne shape) into rounds. Makes short work of the rolling by hand. Also I cut onions in the butter and saute until tender and pour over the boiled pierogi.
   #65814
 Teresa Sloan (Florida) says:
My ex-mother ins law..Made the pierogi's for 17 year's I did pay attention but I have never made them myself....She so so sadly is gone now and my kid's want gulinkey's and polish food..I have four polish boy's..lol...so I will learn with help..feel free if anyone read's this
   #64147
 Doris (Michigan) says:
I loved all your pierogi recipes, especially the one with sour cream. Just made 13 dozen today! Potato and cheese and sauerkraut and sausage. I recently purchased a pierogi maker at a kitchen store and have conquered the hardest part keeping them together. What a great little tool! What a fun and easy way to make large quantities to freeze.
   #51698
 Kimberly (Pennsylvania) says:
I make pierogies all the time, just did today in fact for the family I take care of at my job. I used mashed potato with fried onions, and roast beef that has been in a food processor with fried onions. Very yummy and has always been a family favorite.
 #32957
 Judie (United States) says:
I make pierogis all the time. To make the filling I boil the potatoes, mash, and cool then mix with cottage cheese and sauteed onions, salt and pepper to taste. Fill dough circles and simmer in water. Serve with melted butter, sour cream and more sauteed onions.
 #29069
 Corianna (Michigan) says:
This recipe was amazing! I've never made anything like this before though, I did tweek it a little. I didn't have any cabbage or leeks so instead, I used an extra potato and added mozzerella cheese. Yumm! My whole family loved it!
 #29023
 Aida (Oklahoma) says:
My mother would make these when we were young. We would have them as snacks straight from the refrigerator they were so good. She would make a large batch when we went on picnics in the summer and nothing ever tasted so good!

This recipe was the best I've tried and closest to mom's. Did this bring back memories! Thank you for sharing this recipe. It's so wonderful to find these gems that have been tucked away in boxes and sometimes were not even written down.
 #27680
 Sarah (British Columbia) says:
I used the Pierogi dough recipe and it was amazing! I usually fail making the dough, but this one was dumby proof. Thank you. I shall be trying other recipes in the future.
sarah

 

Recipe Index