RUSSIAN TEA CAKE 
6 pkg. of pound cake mix
Red and green food coloring
1 lg. jar raspberry preserves
3 c. granulated sugar
1 1/2 c. water
1 bottle (4 oz.) rum flavoring
1 recipe of white frosting (below)

Prepare one package of pound cake according to package directions. Pour batter into a jelly roll pan that has been greased and lined with greased wax paper. Bake at 350°F for 20 to 30 minutes or until done.

Prepare two more packages of pound cake mix and bake each jelly roll pan in the same manner.

To the fourth mix, add enough red food coloring for a bright red batter. Bake the same as the previous cake. To the fifth cake mix, add green food coloring and bake.

When preparing the sixth pound cake mix, divide the batter in half and make 1 part green and 1 part red. Pour the green batter on 1/2 of the prepared jelly roll pan and the red batter on the other. Bake.

When all cakes have cooled and have been removed from pans, wrap each in aluminum foil and place in freezer.

Meanwhile, make a simple syrup by mixing sugar with water in a medium saucepan. Bring to full boil and boil for 1 minute. Cool.

Working with frozen cakes and a serrated knife, cut one white cake into 1 inch squares. Cut the green cake, the red cake, and the red and green cakes into 1 inch squares also. Place all the squares in a heap in the largest bowl you have!

Mix rum flavoring with 3/4 of the simple syrup. Pour this mixture over the cake squares, turning the squares so everything is moistened.

Remove remaining two cakes from the freezer, they should be the white ones. Sprinkle a clean, dry jelly roll pan with sugar. Place one cake upside down into the pan. Spread with a thin layer of preserves.

Pack the soaked cake squares onto the cake as evenly as possible.

Spread the bottom of the remaining cake with another layer (thin) of preserves. Place this, preserves-side down, on top of the packed squares. Sprinkle sugar on top.

Place a second jelly roll pan on top. Place heavy weights on top of this (a heavy crock or bricks wrapped in a towel) or a 50 pound bag of flour. I find an old crock the handiest to use. Let this stand overnight or for at least 8 hours.

ICING:

1 1/2 c. solid white shortening
1 lb. confectioners' sugar
1 tsp. rum flavoring
2 tbsp. water or more if needed
Red raspberry preserves, as needed

Cream shortening until smooth. Sift in half the sugar. Mix well. Blend rum flavoring and water together. Add to creamed mixture. Sift in remaining sugar and beat until soft and smooth, adding more water, if needed, 1 tablespoon at a time. Add preserves to icing to make a pink color.

Remove weights and top jelly pan from cake. Ice it on top only. Cut 1/2 inch off the edges with a serrated knife. (Dip in hot water for easier cutting.) And that is how to make a Russian Tea Cake.

recipe reviews
Russian Tea Cake
   #192651
 Michael Lannotti (Rhode Island) says:
I have been scouring the internet for over 10 years looking any remanence of what I grew up eating in Cranston as Russian Tea Cake! Ever since Rainbow bakery and about 90% of the bakeries I have enjoyed since the 80s closed I have been on the search for these Bad Larry's! Thank you fellow Rhodies for the recipe hook up! I am now heading to Dave's to gather the ingredients. Let's Gooo!
   #184268
 Joanne Ciullo (Rhode Island) says:
I've made this recipe several times as it is a family favorite!
 #193715
 Ryan Williams (United States) replies:
Did you use rum extract? I'm having a hard time finding rum flavoring other than rum extract. I just don't want it to be too overpowering.
 #182523
 Jan (Florida) says:
I remember a restaurant/diner on the East Side near or on Thayer on a corner. It was well known for Russian Tea cake. Does anyone know the name? This was in the 60s. I had trouble finding a recipe until I finally added "Providence" to the Google search. I remember the colorful layered cake a little differently from the photo and the recipe. I remembered just layers (no cubes) and very much soaked in rum flavoring. Anyone else remember this place?
 #144310
 Edie (Rhode Island) says:
I thought I was losing my mind when I did a web search for Russian Tea Cake and all of these images of Butterballs appeared. It is fabulous to know that it does exist. After looking at the recipe I think I will find the bakery of my childhood and get it there, lol.
   #107716
 Rob (Florida) says:
I grew up in RI and have been living in Maine for a while. Of course when we would visit I would stock up on bakery pizza (RI pizza strips) and Russian tea cake. I've been trying to Google this for about a few years (here and there) but always got pics of those stuuuupid little cake balls that apparently are the real russian tea cakes. Thank you so much for FINALLY giving me hope. I currently live in Wacksonville FL so I am very far from any of our awesome RI bakery. Thanks, Rob
   #107461
 Laury Coleman (Rhode Island) says:
Thank you for posting this recipe! It's exactly as was explained to me by a baker at an Italian bakery here in RI. Everyone else seems to think Butter Balls are Russian tea cakes!! And the baker I knew used bags of flour as weights. :)

This is EXCELLENT! Worth coming to RI just to sample.
   #104529
 Debbie (Rhode Island) says:
This is the closest recipe I have found to the Russian Tea cake from Colliers Bakery, of Providence, RI. Wonderful recipe! Thank you
   #95047
 Cara Castellucci (Rhode Island) says:
Thank you so much for posting this! I have always loved Russian Tea Cake! It is a staple at all Italian bakeries in RI, like carrot or red velvet cake. However, I didn't know that it was limited to RI until tonight. After searching all over the internet, this is the only recipe I found! The shortbread cookies everyone else calls russian tea cakes are Butterballs to me and everyone else in RI I'm sure! Thank you for posting the "Real Russian Tea Cake" (in my little RI world at least). :)
 #53608
 J Berkleigh (United States) says:
This is a popular recipe in some Rhode Island Italian bakeries. I have wanted this recipe for nearly 50 years! Thank You!

 

Recipe Index