RECIPE COLLECTION
“PERFECT APPLE PIE” IS IN:
NEXT RECIPE:  CHICKEN POT PIE

PERFECT APPLE PIE 
I created this recipe because I always felt as though it was wasteful to toss out the apple peels and cores. I became accustomed to using the peels for canning apple jelly, and so I adapted that way of making pectin to create a wonderful, slightly thickened and flavor-infused filling for this unique apple pie.

There is some extra effort involved, but when you're not in a rush, the aroma of apple spices and ginger wafting throughout the house is well worth your time. I hope you enjoy my recipe and thank you for all of your comments -CM

PASTRY:

3/4 cup cake flour
1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
scant teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon sugar
1 tablespoon lard
4 tablespoons Crisco shortening
large pinch Rumford Baking Powder
1 tablespoon buttermilk powder OR:
1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar ADDED TO:
5-7 tablespoons ice water
1 stick plus 1/3 stick butter, frozen in advance

FILLING:

10 apples, peeled and sliced thinly
1/2 cup white sugar
2 tablespoons butter
2 tablespoons brown sugar
1/2 teaspoon ginger
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
sprinkle of mace (optional)
sprinkle of vanilla
lemon juice
flour, cornstarch, or arrowroot for thickening

Preheat oven to 400°F, then reduce to 375°F after pie is in the oven.

Combine dry ingredients. Mix together Crisco and lard in metal bowl. Sprinkle with flour mixture. Chill in refrigerator for 15 minutes. Remove butter from freezer and slice into 1/2 inch chunks. Add to bowl.

Work butter and shortenings together into flour with fingers or a pastry blender, leaving large chunks, the size of walnuts. The purpose is to coat the butter particles with flour, but not to allow the butter or shortenings to melt. Do not overwork the mixture.

Add the lemon juice or vinegar to ice water and stir quickly into dry ingredients. Mix briefly, less than 45 seconds, leave large unincorporated pockets of butter and shortening. If mixture is beginning to melt, refrigerate briefly.

Gather mixture together into a flat disc, approximately 1 inch thick, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 1/2 hour or up to 2 days. Freeze if you want to reserve longer than 2 days. The half hour rest is necessary so that the dough will become easier to roll out. The buttermilk powder and/or lemon juice also helps relax the dough and prevent gluten, which can make for a tough crust.

NOTE: For a flakier pie crust, reserve 1/3 stick of butter and slice lengthwise, 1/8 inch thick. Place strips of butter onto dough and then fold into thirds before refrigerating for half hour resting period.

For the filling, use a combination of different types of apples. The best combination consists of mostly Granny Smith apples and a few Cortland types. The Granny Smith apples retain their shape when cooked and provide tartness and flavor. Meanwhile, the Cortland apples cook down into applesauce.

Mix the nutmeg, ginger, and cinnamon with the sugar. Sprinkle the sugar with a few drops of pure vanilla extract. Work the butter and 2 Tablespoons flour or other thickener into the sugar. Slice the apples into thin wedges and place apples into pre-rolled out and fitted pie crust, packing apples in tightly, since they will cook down significantly. Mound apples higher in center. Sprinkle over the apples the juice of 1/2 lemon, then sprinkle the sugar-spice mixture over the apples evenly.

Roll out and place top crust, fluting edges to seal tightly and creating several vent holes to allow steam to escape. Alternatively, cut the dough into strips to make a woven top lattice pie.

Brush top of crust with a mixture of one egg white and one tablespoon of water or with a little cream. Sprinkle with 1 teaspoon sugar.

Variation: One method of making a nice base for your apple pie is to peel a portion of the apples, placing the skins, cores, lemon peels, cinnamon sticks, and fresh grated ginger, into a saucepan with sugar and half cup of water or apple juice. Simmer over low heat for about an hour and strain, reserving the liquid.

Thicken 1/2 cup of the strained liquid with 1-2 tsp cornstarch or arrowroot and cool. Add 1/4 tsp vanilla, the sliced and peeled apples, and pour into the pie shell. This is a nice variation when you don't have cortland apples to mix in with the granny smiths because it keeps the pie from being too dry. The liquid is enough for one 10-inch pie about 4 inches tall at center. Adjust according to your pie size.

Bake for about 45 minutes, or until crust is golden brown.

I've found that freshly grated ginger much improves the flavor over the ground type in this recipe.

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Perfect Apple Pie
   #97088
 Shikyokage742 (California) says:
This is one of the best recipes I've made. All of my housemates raved about it, and my boyfriend won't stop bragging about it either.
   #95586
 Debby (Kansas) says:
The best apple pie I have ever had. I wanted to try making crusts again and this is by far the most amazing and worth the effort. Thanks so much for taking the time to submit such a detailed recipe. All the best.
   #87543
 Mike (Ohio) says:
This is the first pie I ever made it turned out excellent and unbelievable flavor. Thanxx
 #79166
 Vickie (Tennessee) says:
I am just beginning to make pie pastry. Yours looks like one I want to try! Thanks.
   #72980
 Carolyn Harman (West Virginia) says:
I am not a pie maker! My daughter Donna is one great cook, and she came to visit us over the week end and our Early Harvest Apple tree is loaded with apples, she made us this pie and let me tell you this is one great pie.. Thanks for sharing it..
   #50850
 Ellen (California) says:
I've not tried your recipe as I have a huge aversion to making pie dough. Always have a fit and misbehave. I buy the crusts premade at Safeway.

CM, you are fabulous. I may try again. Your comprehensive directions make the whole process understandable, the chilling and resting and gluten action.

I just printed (3) recipes by the mysterious CM. My granddaughers are coming over and I looked up a good sugar cookie recipe. We are trying yours tonight! Crisp Autumn Day! Fine time for baking.

Thank you for a well written article. Ellen
   #136236
 Beth (Oklahoma) replies:
I learned to make pie as a girl living on an Oklahoma farm. I've tried so many recipes and my family and friends consider me to be an expert at pie making. I have never seen a recipe for apple pie that is made using this method. I will never go back to making apple pies using another recipe because this recipe excels in every way. Thank you to CM for sharing this great recipe!
 #158224
 Yellow Rose (Texas) replies:
I will probably never make this pie, as it seems too ambitious for me. However, I would like to add that I have made several of CM's recipes and they are always great. Whoever you are, CM, I wish you would move to Texas and cook for us! This pie looks amazing! Perhaps someday I will try to make it.
   #50036
 Alex (Serbia) says:
This really is a perfect pie!
   #49628
 Tj B (Washington) says:
Absolutely the BEST, and I have been making pie for 50 years. This one beat 'em ALL!

 

Recipe Index