COLONIAL PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE
SQUARES (NO COOK)
 
1/2 c. light corn syrup
3/4 c. peanut butter
1/3 c. butter, softened
3/4 c. pecans, chopped
1/2 tsp. salt
1 tsp. vanilla
4 c. Colonial powdered sugar, sifted

Combine syrup, peanut butter, salt, butter and vanilla. Beat until blended. Gradually add sugar, making a very stiff mixture. Turn out on board; knead until well blended, working in pecans. Press into a buttered 8-inch square pan. Chill until firm. Cut into 2-inch squares.

recipe reviews
Colonial Peanut Butter Fudge Squares (No Cook)
 #191295
 Maddison (Utah) says:
It never says when it was published. I don't think it is the real recipe because there are ingredients that they didn't have in the 1700s. Still, they were good.
   #190728
 Ryleee (Georgia) says:
It was the best. Made for a school project. I would recommend.
   #189946
 OPmaster15 (California) says:
I used this recipe. Thanks!
   #189925
 OP (California) says:
I used this for a 1607 Jamestown project. Thank you Cooks.com
   #186998
 Isis (Florida) says:
This recipe is amazing. I've been making it since I discovered it for a school project 10 years ago. I've tried it without any corn syrup and it came out just fine as well. Like others have said, I recommend cutting down the amount of powdered sugar a bit.
 #181783
 Sandra (California) says:
What was the original recipe since corn syrup wasn't around in the
1700s?
   #175086
 Allison (Wisconsin) says:
This sounds yummy. I need to make something for my class and I am choosing this!
 #169564
 Evelyn Marris (Florida) says:
I'm gonna make this for a school project as well! From the reviews I've seen, I'm guessing it's something worth making! X3
 #160116
 Miranda Kendall (United States) says:
Yum! Awesome, but cut down on the sugar!
   #153428
 My man (California) says:
I used for project lots of sugar !!! Good
   #138465
 Chloe (Michigan) says:
Awesome!!!
   #112805
 Caca (Arizona) says:
I made this for a project too!!!
   #111136
 Nina (Iowa) says:
I was really impressed with this recipe! It is amazing! Almost better than the fudge at Scheel's! :)
   #85589
 Catherine M. (Wisconsin) says:
I made this for a project too! :) it seems to be a trend... Its very good! I think I may bring it for my birthday treat! :) I will make it with less sugar though!
   #84816
 Danny (Georgia) says:
I made it 4 a project 2!

 

Recipe Index