OLD FASHIONED POT ROAST 
4 to 6 lb. boneless pot roast, rolled rump or chuck
2 onions, coarsely chopped
2 carrots, sliced
1 stalk celery, coarsely chopped

Dredge meat in flour and brown thoroughly on all sides in Dutch oven using oil or bacon grease. As it si browning, add onion, carrot, and celery (allow vegetables to brown, too!) After meat is browned, add about 1 1/2 cups water. Cover tightly. Cook over low heat for 3 to 4 hours, adding more liquid, if needed.

When meat is fork tender, remove to platter and keep warm. Strain juices in pan, skim off fat. Add more water if stock tastes too strong. Thicken with flour and water mixture. Add salt and pepper to taste.

You may also add potatoes and carrots during the last 45 minutes of cooking for a one-dish meal. The secret to a really good pot roast is the browning.

Let the meat get good and dark and your meat and gravy will have rich full flavor. We always serve cole slaw, glazed carrots and plenty of mashed potatoes along with our pot roast for a real old fashioned dinner!

recipe reviews
Old Fashioned Pot Roast
 #19719
 Valeri Johnson says:
If you are using the stock/juices for gravy use cornstarch. Fat gravies use flour (roux). You could also use red wine instead of some of the added water. But if you want to use flour, make sure you mix the flour into some of the hot liquid to make a paste and then mix the thickened flour into the other juices. Cornstarch is used for water gravies. Cornstarch can dull flavor if too much is used so be sure that you taste the gravy and add salt/pepper/spices to bring up the flavor. Bring the liquid to a boil before you add the cornstarch or flour paste. You could also add just a few pats of butter instead of either cornstarch or flour.
   #164708
 Alane Leibner (North Carolina) says:
This was originally a recipe my mom had submitted for a company cookbook. I suppose you could use cornstarch, however, this recipe calls for dredging the meat in flour and browning it. After years of making this recipe, I add extra fat (a little butter and oil) to the drippings and vegetables and sprinkle them with flour allowing it to brown nicely before adding the water and meat back in. I rarely even have to thicken the gravy, but will add water, as needed, if not using a crockpot. Using red wine would be fine, but will totally alter the flavor, losing the beauty of this recipe... it's beef at its simple finest.

 

Recipe Index