AMISH PRIME RIB 
5 lbs. prime rib roast

Five pounds would take 5 hours. Roast at 200 degrees 1 hour per pound. Slash deep with a knife and twist to make openings in the roast. Stuff in the following:

2 tsp. dry mustard
Paprika
1/4 tsp. allspice
Salt & pepper

Put in the pockets made with knife. Slice small pieces of garlic and onion and put pieces in also. Rub in leftover spices over roast.

recipe reviews
Amish Prime Rib
 #20093
 jan hoekstra (Michigan) says:
If I cook my 10 pound prime rib roast at 200°F 1 hour per pound will it still be med.rare?
 #20122
 EllenG (United States) says:
For best results, always use a meat thermometer! All roasts have different amount of fat and bone, nobody can tell you when it will be cooked except a thermometer. Cheap investment! For medium rare 150°F is about right.
 #56460
 Toohot (Florida) says:
150°F is waaay beyond med. rare !!!
   #66886
 Lyn (Pennsylvania) says:
150 degrees is correct for rare to medium rare
 #184044
 Chef Boy RPD (Pennsylvania) replies:
Limecat is spot on... 150°F is way to overcooked... I would pull it out at 120-125°F... Let it rest to finish 125-130°F... The ends will be more well done and the center will be more rare.
 #88093
 Limecat Ricky (Georgia) says:
Medium Rare Temperature: 130-135°F after resting.

Well I don't know how beef cooks in your part of the world, but I just made a 10 lb. standing rib roast today, perfectly medium rare to medium. I smoked it (yum!) in my kettle grill, but the same temperatures apply. Using my remote sensing thermometer I let the internal temperature rise to 125°F, then let the roast rest under foil and a towel until the internal temp rose to 135°F. I think next time I'll go 5 degrees less, and get a little more toward MR- to rare.

This is the first time I've used the remote thermometer and I'm excited about it. I don't have to open the grill (or oven) and lose the heat in order to measure the temp any more. Plus the device has a sensor for the temp inside the grill, so I know when to add more fuel.

 

Recipe Index