EASY LEMON ICE BOX PIE 
1 small can sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup lemon juice
1 graham cracker crust
1 small tub Cool Whip

Mix everything together until smooth and pour into pie crust. Refrigerate until set about 1 hour.

Easy as pie!

Submitted by: Melody M.

recipe reviews
Easy Lemon Ice Box Pie
 #13726
 trina says:
Hi Ms, Melody, I fixed your lemon pie recipe and all of my friends thought I bought it. I love this recipe it's so easy to do. Thanks you, Trina
 #14169
 Ezra B says:
I love Ice Box pie my mom use to make it when I young. She use to do the same recipe but would use can frozen juice lemon, pink lemonade or grape. All three are great.
 #19786
 Lobeth says:
This recipe is also great using 1/2 cup lime juice for key lime pie and use a couple drops of green food coloring!!
 #28751
 Marcella (Georgia) says:
Wow, was easy to fix for a dinner party and I hoped some would be left over . . . No luck. Pie consumed fast and all asked for recipe!
 #38406
 Connie (Oregon) says:
VERY EASY! Great summer time dessert. It was a HUGE hit!
 #40779
 Rajone (Texas) says:
This is my favorite pie! I must try this recipe out myself.
   #56146
 Carolyn (South Carolina) says:
Our family has used this recipe over 35 yrs and it is always a must at family gathering.
 #57069
 Debbie G (Arkansas) says:
This pie is also really good using crushed vanilla wafers as the bottom crust with whole cookies lining the edge of the pie dish. I also use fresh lemons and a little lemon zest. Can also use a store bought NILLA CRUST. The cookies make it fun to regulate the size of piece you want. 1 cookie, 2 cookies, etc.
   #61005
 Michelle (South Carolina) says:
Easiest and tastiest lemon pie around. Great/simple recipe! Will use over and over again!!!
   #72453
 Debbie Nance (Colorado) says:
Thank you Miss Melody! Making this for my 91 year old Mom for July 4th! She made it just like you do after Cool Whip hit the market! Thank you for sharing your recipe - it was thrill to be able to make my Mom so happy.
   #85179
 Lisa K. Tubbs (Michigan) says:
Thank you so much my mom passed in 2004 and she used to make this every year for Thanksgiving and I didn't know how to make. Thank you so much.
 #85389
 Karen (Wisconsin) says:
Thank you so much for the recipe, my great aunt used to make this all the time in the summer, I somehow lost the recipe and couldn't remember how to make it.
   #92395
 Momto2Puppies (New York) says:
This is a wonderful and easy recipe. I showed my son (age 13) today how to make it. I think it is important to demonstrate to kids they can also make quick and delicious meals and desserts. Thanks so much.
   #97528
 Lee (Tennessee) says:
I added some fresh lemon zest and slices to this recipe just for looks when I made this for my now boyfriend. I think this is what won him over on our first date. Thanks so much!
   #101137
 Suzanne (Texas) says:
Very easy to make and very good. I substituted lime juice for lemon, the pie is very light a perfect dessert after a dinner. I will definitely be making this again. Thank you Melody.

Related recipe search

“LEMON ICE BOX PIE”

 

Recipe Index