PENNSYLVANIA DUTCH POTATO SALAD 
8 boiled potatoes
1 stalk celery diced
2 hard cooked eggs sliced
1 onion minced
1 tablespoon minced parsley
2 eggs well beaten
1 cup sugar (or to taste)
1/2 cup cider vinegar diluted with
1/2 cup cold water
1/4 tsp. dry mustard
1/2 tsp. salt
1/4 tsp. pepper
4 slices bacon

Even people who do not like potato salad like this. I myself have never been crazy about potato salad with mayonnaise because living in PA Dutch country I have been raised on the PA Dutch style potato salad.

Boil potatoes in their jackets. When tender, peel and dice. (I leave skins on) Add celery, hard cooked eggs and onion. Fry bacon in skillet until crisp and brown. (Do not drain)

Beat the eggs, add the sugar, spices, vinegar and water. Mix well. Pour the egg mixture into the hot bacon and fat and stir until mixture thickens (about 10 minutes).

Pour over potatoes and stir to mix well. Refrigerate for several hours or overnight stirring once or twice.

Part of this recipe we also use for hot bacon dressing that you can use to pour over lettuce for a hot salad.

Hot Bacon Dressing:

2 eggs, well beaten
1 cup sugar (or to taste)
1/2 cup cider vinegar, diluted with:
1/2 cup cold water
1/4 tsp. dry mustard
1/2 tsp. salt
1/4 tsp. pepper
4 slices bacon

Make the same as above but pour dressing over a plate of lettuce for a very tasty salad.

recipe reviews
Pennsylvania Dutch Potato Salad
 #37451
 Karen (United States) says:
This is the best and only way to make potato salad! Pa. Dutch potato salad does not contain mayonnaise!
   #72474
 CFry (West Virginia) replies:
It does have mayo. You are just making it with the salad.
   #75535
 Jack Ewing (Arizona) says:
My wife and I prepared this recipe and it turned out to be excessively sweet. We were very disappointed. Even half as much sugar might be too much.
   #91659
 Teresa Brown (Ohio) says:
I've looked every where for this, my mother made this for me as a child. It was soo good! She made this in the sixties so now I'm going to try it wish me luck. I cant wait to taste this....
 #107154
 Susie Farnes (Pennsylvania) says:
I hope and pray this is the recipe that my cousin Lawrence wants me to make for our Buffenmyer Family Reunion. My mom always made this every year and she has been gone now 11 years and I told him that I will try and find it and I did!!!! Yeah, for me, thank you soooo much, I will let you know how it went over with all my uncles and aunts that have not had this recipe forever. I feel like a kid again! =)
   #178625
 Phyllis (Virginia) says:
Thank you - thank you. I have searched for the Hot Bacon Dressing... for YEARS! My mother used to make this.

You have made my day... my year... Now can hardly wait to share with my son & his family...

Related recipe search

“POTATO SALAD”

 

Recipe Index