Oh, I was so glad to find my childrens favorite peanut butter cookies. I use to make this around Christmas time, but I use M&M's instead of choc chips. I thought for christmas I would give them each a tine of Christmas memories. Thank you for having this, how I lost my recipe I don't know. My grandchildren will have the pleasure of helping grandma make these. I do remember the stirring could be hard. Or maybe divide the recipe and thirds and let them have their own bowl.