RECIPE COLLECTION
“PEANUT BUTTER - IRISH POTATO CANDY” IS IN:

PEANUT BUTTER - IRISH POTATO
CANDY
 
2 (1 lb. ea.) boxes confectioners' sugar, sifted
1/2 cup hot mashed potatoes, drained
1 small jar crunchy peanut butter

Mix sifted sugar into potatoes a little at a time by hand. (Don't panic when potatoes liquefy as the first sugar is added. This is what it's supposed to do. Just keep adding sugar until it is of pastry consistency).

Sprinkle wax paper with additional confectioners' sugar. Take baseball-sized ball of mixture and roll out like pastry. Spread with peanut butter and roll like a jelly roll. Wrap rolls in plastic wrap; chill and slice.

Makes 2 rolls.

recipe reviews
Peanut Butter - Irish Potato Candy
   #78809
 Shannon (Ohio) says:
My family doesn't get it, LOL, but I loved it as a kid. Also, you can kick it up a notch by dipping these slices in chocolate!! YUMMMMY
   #75466
 Devon (Arizona) says:
My sister is Gluten and Dairy free, and I've been searching for a dessert I can make for her birthday that doesn't require driving to the far ends of the earth for ingredients and 40 tries to get it right. A friend of mine made this last St. Patty's day, and I thought they were phenomenal. This recipe will be PERFECT for her birthday. Thank you!
   #64104
 Helen Ramos (New York) says:
This recipe is one Jean Campbell shared with me. I lost it in a move from Lex. Ky. to W.H. Ct. I've done so many different candies based on this recipe. I've dipped in chocolate, spread with P.B. or preserves My favorite i think is taking a can of cherry pie filling and picking out the cherries to dip in chocolate bark then using the filling to flavor the candy (i do make this in extra lg quanties)before dipping into chocolate bark, i've also flavored the candy with other flavorings, cocoanut, rice krispy type cereal (before candy stiffens), maple syrup too. Jeans favotite way to serve it was either rolled pinwheel style or sandwiched as a andies candy P.B or chocolate in the middle. Holidays are not the same without the Campbells and Jeans potato candy. I'm glad i found the recipe again.
   #57773
 Lauren (Vermont) says:
My Dad made this every winter when I was a kid in the 50's, and I have searched for this candy recipe. Thank you so much ...what wonderful memories...
 #56017
 Alanna Young (North Carolina) says:
My Dad LOVED this candy. I will make it in his honor...always
   #55497
 Mary Jimison (Texas) says:
I grew up with potato candy as well as all my relatives. My grandmother did to, but never knew where it came from. Since bother her parents were full blood Irish, we always assumed it was an Irish candy. So checking the internet and this is my proof. I just made a batch for a party tomorrow. This sounds like old home week to me.
   #54771
 Phyllis Chittum (Virginia) says:
This is the best recipe I have found. I have made two batches so far this year. Other recipes did NOT explain the fact that it is SUPPOSED to liquify. I had always panicked at that point. My mother used to make this as part of the Christmas goodies at our home. This will now become part of my own tradition, as I make candies/cookies for friends and neighbors.
   #54273
 Judy (North Carolina) says:
My mom used to make this when we were little. She has now passed away but she taught me how to make it years ago. I now have to make every christmas for my aunt esther as my mom used to make it for her (as she was my mom's little sister) esther says no one makes it like but me. Love you aunt esther.
   #53550
 Lisa (Illinois) says:
Love love love this recipe always been one of my favorites......... I am going to try the food coloring idea for a festive feel......... The kids really love helping with this candy - great for them to help.
   #51705
 Rodney (Alabama) says:
Thank you for the recipe, my mother made the every year for thanksgiving and christmas. I am going to make it this year, It has been 5 years that my mother passed away. All the family will love it.
 #44613
 Amanda (North Carolina) says:
My grandma got this recipe from her fathers family and every Christmas she made it. I now make it for my husband every few Christmases. I love it. I look forward to having children of my own to share it with.

I want to know the origin of it though.
 #29779
 LORIE (Oklahoma) says:
I looked and looked for this recipe. My dad used to make when I was little and all I could remember was peanut butter and powdered sugar. I didn't even know what it was called. Thanks so much for the recipe
 #27517
 Lady Di (Pennsylvania) says:
I've been receiving this as a Christmas gift for years, never knew how it was made, so I tried it with chocolate confectioner's sugar on the outside - great, peanut butter and chocolate... just for a little change :-)
 #24210
 Kathy K. in Pa. (Pennsylvania) says:
My mother made this when I was a child, she would use smooth peanut butter on half, then smooth peanut butter and sprinkle raisins and roll up. Great!
 #23451
 Terri Minser (Virginia) says:
Has anyone tried making this using mashed sweet potatoes? If so, what did you think of them? I need to make something for a potluck in 2 weeks and it has to be on the theme of a build your own potato bar and salad.

Related recipe search

“PEANUT BUTTER CANDY”

 

Recipe Index