RECIPE COLLECTION
“AMISH CHICKEN CASSEROLE” IS IN:

AMISH CHICKEN CASSEROLE 
8 oz. broad egg noodles
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter
8 oz. sliced fresh mushrooms
1/3 cup all-purpose flour
2 cups chicken broth
1 cup milk
salt and pepper, to taste
1/3 cup freshly grated Parmesan cheese
2 cups cooked chicken, cut into cubes
generous pinch of rubbed sage

Cook noodles as directed on package. Melt butter and cook mushrooms in a large skillet until lightly browned. Stir in flour and blend in with a fork or slotted spoon. Stir in milk and broth and seasonings; whisk sauce constantly until thickened.

Combine sauce, noodles and chicken. Adjust seasonings to taste. Place in a 2-quart casserole dish. Sprinkle top with Parmesan cheese and bake at 350°F for 30 minutes.

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Amish Chicken Casserole
 #16507
 DW says:
This recipe was really simple yet really delicious! A keeper for certain.
 #35837
 Gene (Georgia) says:
This is an exceptional recipe that I highly recommend. A great blend of flavors. I added one other dimension of flavor by adding 4 crumbled bacon strips. Thanks for lunch!
 #44201
 Luanne Malksian (South Carolina) says:
I Love IT!! I e-mailed this to my daughter and when she made it she couldn't keep the kids out of it. I have made it twice and my husband AND I LOVE IT. Knowing my family's likes I added a few cloves of garlic and a tsp. of catsup. One of my favorite flavor enhancers. I am using the sauce recipe in other recipes and it is wonderful. Thank you for sharing.
 #46880
 AmandaR (Indiana) says:
This recipe is AWESOME! I left out the mushrooms since my toddlers won't eat them but I added peas and they LOVE it! I can't get them to eat green veggies so I try to hide them in other dishes and this one works PERFECT! It is so tasty they don't even realize they're eating veggies.

Thank you for the WONDERFUL recipe!
   #51192
 BerniceB (Wisconsin) says:
What an amazing, comforting, warm recipe! Made it with a side of fresh carrots and it was DEVOURED by all. I now have a use for my left-over Sunday baked chicken! That sauce is divine; am already thinking of other recipes I can use it with... chicken and gravy with buttermilk biscuits is coming to mind, and chicken pot-pies... Awesome! And, yes, INCREDIBLY EASY to put together in a hurry! We didn't even bake ours, just sprinkled the cheese on top and put it on the table.
   #57080
 Cinderella11052 (Rhode Island) says:
Very easy and my husband loved it. I added peas as one review mentioned. I also used whole wheat noodles to cut fat, calories and add fiber - couldn't tell the difference. This one is a keeper.
   #59242
 Frances (Texas) says:
I was so surprised. This was really a great recipe. My husband is not a casserole person but he really liked this. I probably added more cheese then 1/3 cup. I didn't measure it but I like more cheese.
 #59251
 Jill (New York) says:
This was so good. I didnt have chicken so I substituted with pepper steak. And I used peppers and inions in place of the mushrooms. Beef broth instead on chicken brother. Great sauce. I can not wait to try the original. BTW, my fiacee love the dish, ate it all to himself.
   #60391
 Amy (British Columbia) says:
Super easy, very yummy.
   #60435
 Maryanne (Illinois) says:
I really liked this recipe. It was really easy to make and tasted delish!! The family liked it too. Thanks!!
   #66547
 Sarah (District of Columbia) says:
This recipe is great! Super easy to prepare & my husband loved it! I cut the butter in half & used rosemary instead of sage. It was perfect!!
   #69979
 Aya (Washington) says:
Absolutely delicious and so versatile! I've made this many times, often throwing in oregano, garlic, and whatever veggies I happen to have. Really yummy sautéing onions and garlic along with the mushrooms. Also excellent topped with biscuits (2 c flour, tbsp baking powder, salt, 1/3 c oil, 2/3 c milk). I usually add them halfway through, and broil at the end to lightly brown them.
   #81413
 Nicole (Iowa) says:
I LOVE this recipe I am making it for my family and consumer science class project!!
   #85906
 Dawn (Texas) says:
It was great. I replaced the mushrooms with a can of corn, green beans, and carrots and also added a can of cream of chicken soup condensed.
   #92743
 Connie (Maryland) says:
So good! I used bone-in chicken pieces simmered 4-5 hrs in a couple of cups of broth with 1 tsp poultry seasoning. Used some of the broth with the liquid to cook the noodles. Lots of flavor. Week nights I will use the crockpot for the chicken and throw it together after work. Perfect with peas & carrots.

 

Recipe Index