ORIGINAL CONEY ISLAND HOT DOG
SAUCE
 
1 tbsp. butter
1 1/2 lbs. ground beef (lean)
2 med. onions, chopped
1 clove garlic, crushed
1 tbsp. prepared reg. mustard
1 (6 oz.) can tomato sauce
6 oz. can water
4 or 5 wieners
1 tbsp. butter
Salt and pepper to taste
2 tbsp. chili powder

Combine everything except wieners and simmer until thick. Grind the wieners and add to sauce. Stir. Cook 15 minutes longer. (Do not brown ground beef first.) Now, some chefs, if the sauce was a little thin, added a few crumbled soda crackers to the sauce. Put over hot dogs in a bun.

recipe reviews
Original Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce
   #63481
 Tlmahoney (Alaska) says:
Was wonderful hubby loved and the girls at the office just went nuts, we dont have anything like here in K-town AK. It didn't think it was to thin at all freezes well.
   #126447
 Steve (Connecticut) says:
I have been trying to find a good Coney Island recipe for a very long time, with a few modifications, this is one of the best
   #187212
 Nickaroo (Oregon) says:
Been making this recipe for many years. One of my favorites. Have never had anyone tell me they didn't like it when I serve it. Will hand this one down to my kids.

 

Recipe Index