RECIPE COLLECTION
“PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES” IS IN:
NEXT RECIPE:  PECAN FINGERS

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES 
1 1/2 cups all purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
large pinch of salt
1/2 cup butter
1/2 cup peanut butter
1/2 cup white sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar
1 egg, beaten
1 tsp. vanilla

Whisk together flour, baking soda and salt.

Cream together butter and peanut butter until well blended and smooth, adding the sugar gradually to mixture. Beat until mixture is light and fluffy.

Add 1 egg, well beaten; stir in vanilla. When well mixed, add flour mixture, stirring until mixed. To avoid tough cookies, do not beat - stir only until mixed.

Drop by the teaspoonful onto a greased or parchment-lined baking sheet and press a criss-cross pattern onto the top using the tines of a fork that has been dipped into flour.

Bake in a preheated 350°F oven for 8 minutes. Do not overbake.

Makes about 3 dozen.

Submitted by: CM

recipe reviews
Peanut Butter Cookies
   #48598
 Crissy (Colorado) says:
These are simply delicious CM! They only take a few minutes to prep and then.. TADA! Delicious soft homemade cookies from SCRATCH. I was so pleasantly surprised making my second batch today... and I know they will be great! I didn't sift the ingredients the first time, I did today. Made the cookies easier to handle. LOVE LOVE LOVE this recipe. Gonna have to look for a simple cheesecake one.
   #84570
 Dan (United Kingdom) replies:
This cookie recipe is amazing, I will definitely be making them again! I think I probably made then a bit bigger than they should have been but I just adjusted the cooking time. Love it, great recipe CM!
   #129911
 T (United States) replies:
This was GREAT! I made it and came out good, except I added a tablespoon of whole milk to the mix and mixed it before I baked the cookies. Yum! Thanks CM
   #48850
 Tiffany (Oregon) says:
Substituted Almond butter (peanut allergy) and added a little extra salt. Dough was crumbly but made perfect cookies! I also had to cook them 10 minutes to get them to set up.
   #51954
 Greta Tjernberg (Washington) says:
Made these cookies and they are yummy, gave some to son-in-law for his B.D and he said delicious !
   #54407
 Greta Tjernberg (Washington) replies:
Have made cookies many years, not as often now at 71, made these peanut butter cookies and they are yuuuumy and what a easy recipe. This is a keeper! ! !
   #54683
 Beckie moyer (Pennsylvania) says:
I always make cookies to give out for Christmas and made these and they are wonderful! I know everyone will enjoy them!
   #57285
 Penny (Connecticut) says:
These were easy enough for my 9 yr old to make alone and they came out great. She did an awesome job and they tasted great :)
   #59631
 Sandra (South Dakota) says:
This recipe was awesome to make and they came out good and they were easy to make for my 2 year old kid
   #62490
 David (Georgia) says:
Hi, I made these cookies and they turned out great. I give this recipe 5 stars.
   #62784
 Mary (North Carolina) says:
I just made some. The recipe was simple and the cookies turned out great!
   #65703
 Mee (New York) says:
I love these cookies... and the dought is Great too =]
   #67690
 Hanna C (Germany) says:
Thank you! I added about a cup of plumped raisins and even more peanut butter. It turned out great!
   #74306
 Celina (California) says:
These cookies were really good! Very easy to make! My kids love them!
   #79924
 Athy (Ontario) says:
5 Stars! Absolutely scrumptious. Extremely easy to make. Made 4 batches in under 2 hours. I like big cookies so each batch made 2 dozen. Will definitely be making these often.
   #83650
 Marcine (Illinois) says:
Add a Hershey Kiss in the middle after they come out of the oven extra tasty.
   #87198
 Beulah (India) says:
This was my first time baking any kind of cookie. I just followed the recipe and the cookies turned out great!! Thanks :)
   #88892
 Adrienne (United States) says:
I made this with Smuckers all natural creamy peanut butter. The batter was very dry and crumbly... but could be packed into a small cookie shape. They still cooked up very nice. 5 stars for flavor!!!

 

Recipe Index